HiFive Unmatched - some benchmarking results
No sooner did I receive my SiFive HiFive Unmatched board than did the questions about the performance of the board start to come in - from far and wide. Prior to receiving the board, articles about the performance of the Freedom U740 SOC compared it with Arm Cortex-A55 cores. I’ve had a range of Arm based systems over the years, so this helped to set my expectation ahead of time in terms of performance. What was promising about the Unmatched boars is the fact that it has a PCIe slot (for a GPU) and the possibility to use NVMe storage. And as Unmatched boards started to arrive out in the wild, posts regarding performance of the board appeared in the [SiFive forums] (https://forums.sifive.com/t/relative-cpu-performance/4373/2 ).
Now that I’ve had the board setup for a few weeks, I decided to run a series of benchmarks on the board, with an HPC flavour. I’ve setup my Unmatched board effectively as a desktop system. I’ve installed both a GPU as well as and NVMe SSD in the system (details below). The system has been installed with Ubuntu 21.04 and has been configured to boot with the CPU clock speed at 1.4 GHz following the procedure here.
For the record, I’ve configured a full desktop running KDE Plasma and I’m actually writing this post in Emacs running on the Unmatched. It’s not quite up to being a desktop replacement, but I can happily use it for less intense tasks as well as programming, etc.
NVIDIA GeForce GT 1030
root@unmatched:/home/ubuntu# lshw -c display
*-display
description: VGA compatible controller
product: GP108 [**GeForce GT 1030**]
vendor: NVIDIA Corporation
physical id: 0
bus info: pci@0000:07:00.0
logical name: /dev/fb0
version: a1
width: 64 bits
clock: 33MHz
capabilities: pm msi pciexpress vga_controller bus_master cap_list rom fb
configuration: depth=32 driver=nouveau latency=0 mode=1920x1200 visual=truecolor xres=1920 yres=1200
resources: iomemory:200-1ff iomemory:200-1ff irq:93 memory:61000000-61ffffff memory:2000000000-200fffffff memory:2010000000-2011ffffff ioport:0(size=128) memory:60800000-6087ffffSamsung SSD 970 EVO Plus 250GB
root@unmatched:/home/ubuntu# lshw -c storage
*-storage
description: Non-Volatile memory controller
product: NVMe SSD Controller SM981/PM981/PM983
vendor: Samsung Electronics Co Ltd
physical id: 0
bus info: pci@0000:06:00.0
version: 00
width: 64 bits
clock: 33MHz
capabilities: storage pm msi pciexpress msix nvm_express bus_master cap_list
configuration: driver=nvme latency=0
resources: irq:38 memory:60500000-60503fff
*-nvme0
description: NVMe device
product: Samsung SSD 970 EVO Plus 250GB
physical id: 0
logical name: /dev/nvme0
version: 2B2QEXM7
serial: S59BNXXX2065XXX
configuration: nqn=nqn.2014.08.org.nvmexpress:144dXXXdS59BNJ0XXX6509J Samsung SSD 970 EVO Plus 250GB state=liveHigh-Performance Linpack (HPL)
Although I did previously run HPL on Unmatched, that was prior to the changes needed to boot the system at 1.4 GHz. Furthermore, some helpful individuals on Twitter actually pointed out an issue with my HPL run (based on the massive run queue lengths I observed). You can view the thread on Twitter here.
Now running at a blistering 1.4 GHz, I'm giving Linpack another whirl on the #Unmatched board. Will definitely break 2 GFlops this time. #SiFive #HiFive #RISCV https://t.co/GOV9ISOUCJ pic.twitter.com/nAwNRNXZWm
— Gábor SAMU (@gabor_samu) June 28, 2021
With the folly of my MPI ways better understood, I ran HPL to completion with a result of 2.5 GFlops. I’ve not devoted more time to squeeze more performance from the system yet, as this result still seems low to me.
ubuntu@unmatched:~/hpl-2.3/bin/Linux_RISCV$ export OMP_NUM_THREADS=1
ubuntu@unmatched:~/hpl-2.3/bin/Linux_RISCV$ mpirun --hostfile ./hostfile ./xhpl
================================================================================
HPLinpack 2.3 -- High-Performance Linpack benchmark -- December 2, 2018
Written by A. Petitet and R. Clint Whaley, Innovative Computing Laboratory, UTK
Modified by Piotr Luszczek, Innovative Computing Laboratory, UTK
Modified by Julien Langou, University of Colorado Denver
================================================================================
An explanation of the input/output parameters follows:
T/V : Wall time / encoded variant.
N : The order of the coefficient matrix A.
NB : The partitioning blocking factor.
P : The number of process rows.
Q : The number of process columns.
Time : Time in seconds to solve the linear system.
Gflops : Rate of execution for solving the linear system.
The following parameter values will be used:
N : 35712
NB : 96
PMAP : Row-major process mapping
P : 2
Q : 2
PFACT : Right
NBMIN : 4
NDIV : 2
RFACT : Crout
BCAST : 1ringM
DEPTH : 1
SWAP : Mix (threshold = 64)
L1 : transposed form
U : transposed form
EQUIL : yes
ALIGN : 8 double precision words
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
- The matrix A is randomly generated for each test.
- The following scaled residual check will be computed:
||Ax-b||_oo / ( eps * ( || x ||_oo * || A ||_oo + || b ||_oo ) * N )
- The relative machine precision (eps) is taken to be 1.110223e-16
- Computational tests pass if scaled residuals are less than 16.0
================================================================================
T/V N NB P Q Time Gflops
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WR11C2R4 35712 96 2 2 11941.62 2.5428e+00
HPL_pdgesv() start time Thu Jul 8 16:26:11 2021
HPL_pdgesv() end time Thu Jul 8 19:45:12 2021
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
||Ax-b||_oo/(eps*(||A||_oo*||x||_oo+||b||_oo)*N)= 4.76417669e-03 ...... PASSED
================================================================================
Finished 1 tests with the following results:
1 tests completed and passed residual checks,
0 tests completed and failed residual checks,
0 tests skipped because of illegal input values.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
End of Tests.
================================================================================STREAM
Up next is STREAM, which is used to test memory bandwidth. I ran stream using the default settings for memory size.
ubuntu@unmatched:~/STREAM$ ./stream_c.exe
-------------------------------------------------------------
STREAM version $Revision: 5.10 $
-------------------------------------------------------------
This system uses 8 bytes per array element.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Array size = 10000000 (elements), Offset = 0 (elements)
Memory per array = 76.3 MiB (= 0.1 GiB).
Total memory required = 228.9 MiB (= 0.2 GiB).
Each kernel will be executed 10 times.
The *best* time for each kernel (excluding the first iteration)
will be used to compute the reported bandwidth.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Number of Threads requested = 4
Number of Threads counted = 4
-------------------------------------------------------------
Your clock granularity/precision appears to be 1 microseconds.
Each test below will take on the order of 91364 microseconds.
(= 91364 clock ticks)
Increase the size of the arrays if this shows that
you are not getting at least 20 clock ticks per test.
-------------------------------------------------------------
WARNING -- The above is only a rough guideline.
For best results, please be sure you know the
precision of your system timer.
-------------------------------------------------------------
Function Best Rate MB/s Avg time Min time Max time
Copy: 1349.8 0.121990 0.118533 0.132665
Scale: 1175.2 0.138145 0.136152 0.149729
Add: 1306.3 0.186115 0.183730 0.196969
Triad: 1315.8 0.185806 0.182400 0.193755
-------------------------------------------------------------
Solution Validates: avg error less than 1.000000e-13 on all three arrays
-------------------------------------------------------------IOzone
Next, I wheeled out IOzone to benchmark the filesystem (on the NVMe SSD). The full output from IOzone can be viewed below.
ubuntu@unmatched:~$ time iozone -a -R -c -b result_file.xls -f ./testfile
Iozone: Performance Test of File I/O
Version $Revision: 3.489 $
Compiled for 64 bit mode.
Build: linux
Contributors:William Norcott, Don Capps, Isom Crawford, Kirby Collins
Al Slater, Scott Rhine, Mike Wisner, Ken Goss
Steve Landherr, Brad Smith, Mark Kelly, Dr. Alain CYR,
Randy Dunlap, Mark Montague, Dan Million, Gavin Brebner,
Jean-Marc Zucconi, Jeff Blomberg, Benny Halevy, Dave Boone,
Erik Habbinga, Kris Strecker, Walter Wong, Joshua Root,
Fabrice Bacchella, Zhenghua Xue, Qin Li, Darren Sawyer,
Vangel Bojaxhi, Ben England, Vikentsi Lapa,
Alexey Skidanov, Sudhir Kumar.
Run began: Thu Jul 8 21:24:44 2021
Auto Mode
Excel chart generation enabled
Include close in write timing
Command line used: iozone -a -R -c -b result_file.xls -f ./testfile
Output is in kBytes/sec
Time Resolution = 0.000001 seconds.
Processor cache size set to 1024 kBytes.
Processor cache line size set to 32 bytes.
File stride size set to 17 * record size.
random random bkwd record stride
kB reclen write rewrite read reread read write read rewrite read fwrite frewrite fread freread
64 4 54002 117900 312204 435202 410573 129316 271200 142875 444572 106319 120331 286849 378715
64 8 69708 153848 357529 551422 488236 49382 321554 200653 576282 128265 167583 467002 503814
64 16 80398 214781 647135 571375 598110 190947 443837 248136 571375 159991 192730 503814 659861
64 32 77564 245190 679917 633392 633392 264258 435202 274809 492717 134769 173429 359444 385237
64 64 98443 280553 516414 780776 571375 279385 463774 280553 529661 266620 278516 477808 587635
128 4 65641 140659 488594 544601 488594 145936 365764 170879 398625 123084 138554 499970 547377
128 8 85860 179507 544601 597981 624409 184694 465708 231429 826202 166481 147946 408949 387686
128 16 93910 246632 731625 294207 612303 245616 410199 239268 419822 114917 143671 509943 537512
128 32 107658 274080 692017 618653 687585 290859 540217 327199 666253 200339 245168 606767 677178
128 64 106042 256531 606767 670413 653282 317711 533241 338761 649331 164744 195737 492178 517812
128 128 97563 203529 592699 695603 533241 217991 351630 198414 348661 164542 183432 430942 621518
256 4 25934 32372 508929 528987 512818 32245 358056 168092 428843 130406 135167 466275 519266
256 8 87675 196016 557844 602276 560172 186841 436870 264741 515032 178516 188514 585845 618584
256 16 103395 234246 576720 557554 598249 242883 531080 335564 882426 193963 223379 585845 510866
256 32 108845 292508 592636 560172 598249 265003 467290 357937 699594 181442 204959 474937 576411
256 64 104828 340027 768712 670332 817898 364622 703721 414283 828628 264481 320347 802014 792543
256 128 129682 291872 604991 615393 661657 335564 349206 341759 627623 182863 267512 663292 716876
256 256 115533 328180 666586 900936 773140 385433 585526 375459 680960 365242 374935 716876 856386
512 4 69857 144428 546460 582478 531055 142777 420020 177348 367291 112552 118824 355319 392678
512 8 83456 212373 675350 619978 688118 217978 599553 285425 503418 161710 158605 438011 466255
512 16 97062 246644 694797 680918 772252 277352 699322 348063 728502 230743 249858 755144 798675
512 32 96365 245096 451454 430978 582478 248183 433939 374269 850554 227251 268912 748563 784094
512 64 100864 346435 762112 706221 750656 347556 680918 357032 717069 181102 216222 435700 606667
512 128 126577 358283 806171 742096 861818 386947 834037 468493 912733 270914 332901 851903 855978
512 256 81959 223770 480227 437654 528441 194152 431671 257807 667582 145131 208558 584539 695472
512 512 106222 295804 618371 774480 714207 364672 538918 340448 525082 323864 312370 537838 467575
1024 4 65218 117835 409402 473859 473232 144876 396917 187924 466094 140814 145845 557729 374687
1024 8 81385 187129 525969 498788 572677 196919 466296 280867 478291 179459 185537 580181 591201
1024 16 103613 200392 388024 369021 452921 194089 362236 352138 456095 202403 225058 703769 768219
1024 32 98272 210302 471001 490192 642400 277420 605538 391883 634055 256189 277815 749583 804330
1024 64 113273 223326 397211 360170 523788 287254 516917 436134 872286 248899 296556 722230 793189
1024 128 104384 221073 377154 349019 531699 300036 581516 453734 909410 238413 282716 630518 708646
1024 256 117039 212718 321797 337712 437244 272129 506135 434809 874417 202891 240549 585799 679067
1024 512 106755 189909 310199 389078 395674 241279 344788 315671 600963 143099 158049 354815 420506
1024 1024 102544 206918 242204 238307 227960 178371 227153 193896 263773 198264 206540 274372 273864
2048 4 67621 118586 295229 291611 300380 112720 300864 191565 295188 112893 115256 329421 352627
2048 8 81958 147391 335848 309504 377499 160689 370818 276498 327462 138108 144500 376259 403533
2048 16 95172 183562 358484 312057 338069 164470 380729 361440 410337 179192 182987 442442 480399
2048 32 97999 199201 428729 406512 495159 234615 467484 395907 398608 173454 184373 396602 404731
2048 64 109430 221980 395670 380172 442624 211393 334423 425248 333877 190722 205374 436484 476297
2048 128 105490 208768 414576 399926 471694 255327 458893 483020 950865 176432 186811 382151 396437
2048 256 112029 222129 368875 360001 375930 215487 323491 384874 716855 157092 176171 380594 400952
2048 512 100895 205560 350440 358918 357484 218058 343751 401646 843821 134833 138013 277248 284644
2048 1024 102057 171524 119222 203356 200433 168239 216584 197434 282323 116628 122092 230343 233417
2048 2048 91309 153096 178226 192846 190850 155070 195306 154891 187525 153075 158562 196566 192898
4096 4 66648 112502 290992 290353 289795 111273 271941 192725 267537 109812 110244 287843 282248
4096 8 78723 138038 323307 290741 310723 136125 332763 289985 335657 131361 130671 326664 326738
4096 16 91339 158845 351946 302890 343880 158858 342216 367689 343132 152596 147163 338067 341020
4096 32 100225 179615 324645 309247 364058 177072 349164 396857 335381 167334 165267 318956 325340
4096 64 105146 190974 331288 251890 281684 187813 365818 461938 363312 173390 171374 330561 332416
4096 128 108193 188945 312481 305785 339551 186819 345158 492304 336571 170652 168865 310516 317958
4096 256 106900 190078 299239 254932 297848 190413 338707 506365 966746 164082 150516 277278 293915
4096 512 104123 167531 258375 268734 250319 172827 267050 420099 827474 135544 127664 260807 261893
4096 1024 98620 157326 218346 213023 208841 158067 220015 221117 242124 116139 112130 209105 210126
4096 2048 93929 145650 165971 179879 184646 146995 181736 154455 191312 99717 104482 183070 181473
4096 4096 88738 142112 163735 171360 171423 140774 171551 142589 172702 143331 143891 172987 172688
8192 4 65841 110741 282065 282657 277459 109690 260419 193678 269801 106967 106454 280607 281455
8192 8 78737 132677 315256 290982 308596 131899 295965 292717 307058 127962 126110 313196 313079
8192 16 90528 154103 323935 298181 323103 155667 320762 371369 315841 144535 144240 319861 322836
8192 32 98090 171610 321998 295164 326245 170297 315682 405808 327891 159856 157632 323115 323553
8192 64 102402 183487 320338 294367 326542 183755 330043 462696 324783 165574 164260 319251 314342
8192 128 104471 186530 322979 294211 308746 182616 327785 469807 307704 160870 162323 308757 308248
8192 256 103528 181720 293578 274062 294857 179329 303496 508379 294136 146447 150201 280433 286644
8192 512 101430 168594 256594 244398 255992 168462 263349 452168 823642 128695 129724 243165 252691
8192 1024 95799 155619 209916 202450 199985 154110 210856 221903 333823 112200 111518 204121 203129
8192 2048 92977 145702 175608 171498 178584 144194 181762 159601 185932 104202 103452 176134 179028
8192 4096 92238 141487 166700 165515 171348 141248 169064 146623 169690 99166 102031 170414 168824
8192 8192 90378 139526 157680 167601 165843 138495 164806 139352 165531 141163 139726 166399 166068
16384 4 65537 107844 282103 280749 270242 107112 249130 191125 269594 105630 105330 278957 276503
16384 8 77659 132704 313095 288375 300982 130745 297485 293336 304009 125047 125518 308525 310062
16384 16 89579 151110 324307 294989 318389 150588 318730 371619 318042 142514 144111 320895 319214
16384 32 97572 169494 320764 295858 323352 167762 318087 401183 324660 156694 157397 322360 317809
16384 64 101477 179036 318910 285769 320018 176881 314648 452435 323678 161742 161881 314654 315860
16384 128 102795 180331 310138 277826 312082 180186 293963 426964 284701 160913 161278 308800 310074
16384 256 104045 179146 293153 266918 291696 178797 289843 491096 299338 148743 147959 287292 281893
16384 512 100875 168689 252422 239039 253092 167970 254063 446721 266575 127001 129013 248796 253007
16384 1024 95676 153097 201314 195896 200676 154616 204118 289716 472338 111232 110130 199120 203740
16384 2048 92414 145259 176177 169912 177331 144759 176145 164623 188378 103403 103192 175926 176835
16384 4096 90982 141026 166237 161617 166524 139707 168260 147010 164545 101305 101404 168331 169053
16384 8192 91386 140560 164431 161942 165147 139306 163070 143700 166585 97515 101440 168344 166060
16384 16384 89645 137768 152920 160325 160462 135038 162230 136345 162555 135472 137670 162533 160600
32768 64 100518 176971 320112 294827 326020 173802 315206 469434 321128 161501 161534 318898 321566
32768 128 94197 177065 310461 267112 318089 174921 311148 514523 313221 159893 160154 309672 313030
32768 256 103097 176990 290264 270202 299582 175632 289551 523164 291906 149130 148485 289408 294488
32768 512 101035 167780 253540 241526 261351 168100 251639 541467 256591 129784 128800 251369 257644
32768 1024 95768 153873 206025 203363 213993 154402 206577 310768 206605 111571 110994 205200 213604
32768 2048 91379 143551 175813 169633 177196 143577 175918 164190 185869 102097 102274 175730 177497
32768 4096 90523 140886 165943 151238 166411 134797 165923 147228 168261 99992 100757 167505 165933
32768 8192 90276 139845 164569 158580 164541 138526 165586 144846 167084 99890 100325 166179 164616
32768 16384 90288 140233 161049 161259 164707 138540 166524 143497 166659 95763 99373 166405 164719
65536 64 99673 174433 320956 298810 326104 171399 318123 472110 319315 159545 159839 319251 325261
65536 128 102216 178852 315098 292086 317099 176802 309199 514040 314167 159211 159476 312052 319301
65536 256 103198 175205 295177 277020 299460 174958 293350 541848 291703 149396 148300 293892 300441
65536 512 100693 166563 257401 245254 262460 166880 256944 543574 251791 130994 130085 217541 261817
65536 1024 95156 151218 208433 201644 210890 153517 206626 314958 208027 111076 110836 209171 212611
65536 2048 91462 142076 174283 167215 175081 141982 174354 161699 174642 101625 101668 174694 175282
65536 4096 89889 138807 164119 157697 164260 138665 164529 146819 165145 99342 99703 164013 164483
65536 8192 89858 138926 163703 156592 164726 138468 165742 146436 165073 99717 100152 165121 164877
65536 16384 90040 138813 161472 158432 164698 138326 164635 143752 164450 99469 99683 164091 164078
131072 64 99699 173619 326411 298937 326454 172619 321262 474723 320924 159388 159492 325895 326394
131072 128 102334 177498 316453 292966 318546 176234 315274 517680 315511 158517 158811 318138 319006
131072 256 103082 174711 297416 275855 297015 174049 296870 444329 286940 149385 149204 298919 299437
131072 512 100339 166579 260214 240191 259430 166266 259838 555206 256165 130764 130765 260470 259510
131072 1024 95586 153909 212513 201096 213837 153992 211843 325153 210439 111303 111203 212527 213064
131072 2048 91508 142804 173585 165672 176190 142592 176080 164782 175868 101700 101366 176033 176177
131072 4096 90078 139044 164617 157582 164913 138651 165129 147795 165182 99576 99553 164871 164751
131072 8192 90091 139102 163556 157103 163885 138561 163914 146168 164348 99535 99576 164213 163900
131072 16384 90186 139243 163011 157758 164480 138613 164554 146106 164729 99687 99691 164304 164366
262144 64 99714 173404 320209 298489 326041 172291 322327 473060 323206 158794 158988 326698 326258
262144 128 101915 176234 318818 291885 318585 176135 315553 519471 316594 158608 158328 318906 319312
262144 256 101863 174533 299916 275040 297207 174432 297790 544317 296951 149346 149257 299027 299670
262144 512 100486 166724 263070 244355 262700 166282 260518 556339 260549 131056 131044 262557 262988
262144 1024 95380 153078 211833 199591 207545 153018 210888 324728 210223 110796 110729 211268 207711
262144 2048 91384 142689 176506 168217 176610 142538 176400 164159 176496 101693 101779 175330 176267
262144 4096 89877 138476 164624 157385 164681 138474 164734 147854 165146 99457 99474 164752 164337
262144 8192 89777 137822 163119 156010 163126 137962 163258 146106 163272 99228 99301 163170 163176
262144 16384 89746 138290 163080 156668 163621 138319 163816 146164 163653 99030 99000 163817 163616
524288 64 99570 170849 326940 298947 326141 172346 321165 462987 324978 159041 157407 325485 325701
524288 128 101686 175674 320133 292759 319437 175953 316947 520033 318289 158680 155071 319095 319083
524288 256 102589 173927 299620 275856 298894 173725 297501 546112 298252 149043 147016 299433 299173
524288 512 100349 165718 260204 241624 260026 164597 259583 557023 258697 129011 130355 259933 260064
524288 1024 95445 153632 212357 200030 212384 153414 211822 324332 211673 111001 110483 212147 212352
524288 2048 91204 142710 175569 168424 176892 142584 176579 164609 176568 101606 101617 176806 176594
524288 4096 89824 138544 164376 157141 164100 138492 164385 152223 164688 99467 99468 164713 164703
524288 8192 89831 138452 163568 156551 163682 138203 163535 148260 163866 99301 99360 163519 163467
524288 16384 89779 138244 163085 156086 162949 137936 162678 146894 162898 98388 98517 163326 163262
iozone test complete.
Excel output is below:
"Writer report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 54002 69708 80398 77564 98443
"128" 65641 85860 93910 107658 106042 97563
"256" 25934 87675 103395 108845 104828 129682 115533
"512" 69857 83456 97062 96365 100864 126577 81959 106222
"1024" 65218 81385 103613 98272 113273 104384 117039 106755 102544
"2048" 67621 81958 95172 97999 109430 105490 112029 100895 102057 91309
"4096" 66648 78723 91339 100225 105146 108193 106900 104123 98620 93929 88738
"8192" 65841 78737 90528 98090 102402 104471 103528 101430 95799 92977 92238 90378
"16384" 65537 77659 89579 97572 101477 102795 104045 100875 95676 92414 90982 91386 89645
"32768" 0 0 0 0 100518 94197 103097 101035 95768 91379 90523 90276 90288
"65536" 0 0 0 0 99673 102216 103198 100693 95156 91462 89889 89858 90040
"131072" 0 0 0 0 99699 102334 103082 100339 95586 91508 90078 90091 90186
"262144" 0 0 0 0 99714 101915 101863 100486 95380 91384 89877 89777 89746
"524288" 0 0 0 0 99570 101686 102589 100349 95445 91204 89824 89831 89779
"Re-writer report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 117900 153848 214781 245190 280553
"128" 140659 179507 246632 274080 256531 203529
"256" 32372 196016 234246 292508 340027 291872 328180
"512" 144428 212373 246644 245096 346435 358283 223770 295804
"1024" 117835 187129 200392 210302 223326 221073 212718 189909 206918
"2048" 118586 147391 183562 199201 221980 208768 222129 205560 171524 153096
"4096" 112502 138038 158845 179615 190974 188945 190078 167531 157326 145650 142112
"8192" 110741 132677 154103 171610 183487 186530 181720 168594 155619 145702 141487 139526
"16384" 107844 132704 151110 169494 179036 180331 179146 168689 153097 145259 141026 140560 137768
"32768" 0 0 0 0 176971 177065 176990 167780 153873 143551 140886 139845 140233
"65536" 0 0 0 0 174433 178852 175205 166563 151218 142076 138807 138926 138813
"131072" 0 0 0 0 173619 177498 174711 166579 153909 142804 139044 139102 139243
"262144" 0 0 0 0 173404 176234 174533 166724 153078 142689 138476 137822 138290
"524288" 0 0 0 0 170849 175674 173927 165718 153632 142710 138544 138452 138244
"Reader report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 312204 357529 647135 679917 516414
"128" 488594 544601 731625 692017 606767 592699
"256" 508929 557844 576720 592636 768712 604991 666586
"512" 546460 675350 694797 451454 762112 806171 480227 618371
"1024" 409402 525969 388024 471001 397211 377154 321797 310199 242204
"2048" 295229 335848 358484 428729 395670 414576 368875 350440 119222 178226
"4096" 290992 323307 351946 324645 331288 312481 299239 258375 218346 165971 163735
"8192" 282065 315256 323935 321998 320338 322979 293578 256594 209916 175608 166700 157680
"16384" 282103 313095 324307 320764 318910 310138 293153 252422 201314 176177 166237 164431 152920
"32768" 0 0 0 0 320112 310461 290264 253540 206025 175813 165943 164569 161049
"65536" 0 0 0 0 320956 315098 295177 257401 208433 174283 164119 163703 161472
"131072" 0 0 0 0 326411 316453 297416 260214 212513 173585 164617 163556 163011
"262144" 0 0 0 0 320209 318818 299916 263070 211833 176506 164624 163119 163080
"524288" 0 0 0 0 326940 320133 299620 260204 212357 175569 164376 163568 163085
"Re-Reader report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 435202 551422 571375 633392 780776
"128" 544601 597981 294207 618653 670413 695603
"256" 528987 602276 557554 560172 670332 615393 900936
"512" 582478 619978 680918 430978 706221 742096 437654 774480
"1024" 473859 498788 369021 490192 360170 349019 337712 389078 238307
"2048" 291611 309504 312057 406512 380172 399926 360001 358918 203356 192846
"4096" 290353 290741 302890 309247 251890 305785 254932 268734 213023 179879 171360
"8192" 282657 290982 298181 295164 294367 294211 274062 244398 202450 171498 165515 167601
"16384" 280749 288375 294989 295858 285769 277826 266918 239039 195896 169912 161617 161942 160325
"32768" 0 0 0 0 294827 267112 270202 241526 203363 169633 151238 158580 161259
"65536" 0 0 0 0 298810 292086 277020 245254 201644 167215 157697 156592 158432
"131072" 0 0 0 0 298937 292966 275855 240191 201096 165672 157582 157103 157758
"262144" 0 0 0 0 298489 291885 275040 244355 199591 168217 157385 156010 156668
"524288" 0 0 0 0 298947 292759 275856 241624 200030 168424 157141 156551 156086
"Random read report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 410573 488236 598110 633392 571375
"128" 488594 624409 612303 687585 653282 533241
"256" 512818 560172 598249 598249 817898 661657 773140
"512" 531055 688118 772252 582478 750656 861818 528441 714207
"1024" 473232 572677 452921 642400 523788 531699 437244 395674 227960
"2048" 300380 377499 338069 495159 442624 471694 375930 357484 200433 190850
"4096" 289795 310723 343880 364058 281684 339551 297848 250319 208841 184646 171423
"8192" 277459 308596 323103 326245 326542 308746 294857 255992 199985 178584 171348 165843
"16384" 270242 300982 318389 323352 320018 312082 291696 253092 200676 177331 166524 165147 160462
"32768" 0 0 0 0 326020 318089 299582 261351 213993 177196 166411 164541 164707
"65536" 0 0 0 0 326104 317099 299460 262460 210890 175081 164260 164726 164698
"131072" 0 0 0 0 326454 318546 297015 259430 213837 176190 164913 163885 164480
"262144" 0 0 0 0 326041 318585 297207 262700 207545 176610 164681 163126 163621
"524288" 0 0 0 0 326141 319437 298894 260026 212384 176892 164100 163682 162949
"Random write report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 129316 49382 190947 264258 279385
"128" 145936 184694 245616 290859 317711 217991
"256" 32245 186841 242883 265003 364622 335564 385433
"512" 142777 217978 277352 248183 347556 386947 194152 364672
"1024" 144876 196919 194089 277420 287254 300036 272129 241279 178371
"2048" 112720 160689 164470 234615 211393 255327 215487 218058 168239 155070
"4096" 111273 136125 158858 177072 187813 186819 190413 172827 158067 146995 140774
"8192" 109690 131899 155667 170297 183755 182616 179329 168462 154110 144194 141248 138495
"16384" 107112 130745 150588 167762 176881 180186 178797 167970 154616 144759 139707 139306 135038
"32768" 0 0 0 0 173802 174921 175632 168100 154402 143577 134797 138526 138540
"65536" 0 0 0 0 171399 176802 174958 166880 153517 141982 138665 138468 138326
"131072" 0 0 0 0 172619 176234 174049 166266 153992 142592 138651 138561 138613
"262144" 0 0 0 0 172291 176135 174432 166282 153018 142538 138474 137962 138319
"524288" 0 0 0 0 172346 175953 173725 164597 153414 142584 138492 138203 137936
"Backward read report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 271200 321554 443837 435202 463774
"128" 365764 465708 410199 540217 533241 351630
"256" 358056 436870 531080 467290 703721 349206 585526
"512" 420020 599553 699322 433939 680918 834037 431671 538918
"1024" 396917 466296 362236 605538 516917 581516 506135 344788 227153
"2048" 300864 370818 380729 467484 334423 458893 323491 343751 216584 195306
"4096" 271941 332763 342216 349164 365818 345158 338707 267050 220015 181736 171551
"8192" 260419 295965 320762 315682 330043 327785 303496 263349 210856 181762 169064 164806
"16384" 249130 297485 318730 318087 314648 293963 289843 254063 204118 176145 168260 163070 162230
"32768" 0 0 0 0 315206 311148 289551 251639 206577 175918 165923 165586 166524
"65536" 0 0 0 0 318123 309199 293350 256944 206626 174354 164529 165742 164635
"131072" 0 0 0 0 321262 315274 296870 259838 211843 176080 165129 163914 164554
"262144" 0 0 0 0 322327 315553 297790 260518 210888 176400 164734 163258 163816
"524288" 0 0 0 0 321165 316947 297501 259583 211822 176579 164385 163535 162678
"Record rewrite report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 142875 200653 248136 274809 280553
"128" 170879 231429 239268 327199 338761 198414
"256" 168092 264741 335564 357937 414283 341759 375459
"512" 177348 285425 348063 374269 357032 468493 257807 340448
"1024" 187924 280867 352138 391883 436134 453734 434809 315671 193896
"2048" 191565 276498 361440 395907 425248 483020 384874 401646 197434 154891
"4096" 192725 289985 367689 396857 461938 492304 506365 420099 221117 154455 142589
"8192" 193678 292717 371369 405808 462696 469807 508379 452168 221903 159601 146623 139352
"16384" 191125 293336 371619 401183 452435 426964 491096 446721 289716 164623 147010 143700 136345
"32768" 0 0 0 0 469434 514523 523164 541467 310768 164190 147228 144846 143497
"65536" 0 0 0 0 472110 514040 541848 543574 314958 161699 146819 146436 143752
"131072" 0 0 0 0 474723 517680 444329 555206 325153 164782 147795 146168 146106
"262144" 0 0 0 0 473060 519471 544317 556339 324728 164159 147854 146106 146164
"524288" 0 0 0 0 462987 520033 546112 557023 324332 164609 152223 148260 146894
"Stride read report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 444572 576282 571375 492717 529661
"128" 398625 826202 419822 666253 649331 348661
"256" 428843 515032 882426 699594 828628 627623 680960
"512" 367291 503418 728502 850554 717069 912733 667582 525082
"1024" 466094 478291 456095 634055 872286 909410 874417 600963 263773
"2048" 295188 327462 410337 398608 333877 950865 716855 843821 282323 187525
"4096" 267537 335657 343132 335381 363312 336571 966746 827474 242124 191312 172702
"8192" 269801 307058 315841 327891 324783 307704 294136 823642 333823 185932 169690 165531
"16384" 269594 304009 318042 324660 323678 284701 299338 266575 472338 188378 164545 166585 162555
"32768" 0 0 0 0 321128 313221 291906 256591 206605 185869 168261 167084 166659
"65536" 0 0 0 0 319315 314167 291703 251791 208027 174642 165145 165073 164450
"131072" 0 0 0 0 320924 315511 286940 256165 210439 175868 165182 164348 164729
"262144" 0 0 0 0 323206 316594 296951 260549 210223 176496 165146 163272 163653
"524288" 0 0 0 0 324978 318289 298252 258697 211673 176568 164688 163866 162898
"Fwrite report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 106319 128265 159991 134769 266620
"128" 123084 166481 114917 200339 164744 164542
"256" 130406 178516 193963 181442 264481 182863 365242
"512" 112552 161710 230743 227251 181102 270914 145131 323864
"1024" 140814 179459 202403 256189 248899 238413 202891 143099 198264
"2048" 112893 138108 179192 173454 190722 176432 157092 134833 116628 153075
"4096" 109812 131361 152596 167334 173390 170652 164082 135544 116139 99717 143331
"8192" 106967 127962 144535 159856 165574 160870 146447 128695 112200 104202 99166 141163
"16384" 105630 125047 142514 156694 161742 160913 148743 127001 111232 103403 101305 97515 135472
"32768" 0 0 0 0 161501 159893 149130 129784 111571 102097 99992 99890 95763
"65536" 0 0 0 0 159545 159211 149396 130994 111076 101625 99342 99717 99469
"131072" 0 0 0 0 159388 158517 149385 130764 111303 101700 99576 99535 99687
"262144" 0 0 0 0 158794 158608 149346 131056 110796 101693 99457 99228 99030
"524288" 0 0 0 0 159041 158680 149043 129011 111001 101606 99467 99301 98388
"Re-Fwrite report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 120331 167583 192730 173429 278516
"128" 138554 147946 143671 245168 195737 183432
"256" 135167 188514 223379 204959 320347 267512 374935
"512" 118824 158605 249858 268912 216222 332901 208558 312370
"1024" 145845 185537 225058 277815 296556 282716 240549 158049 206540
"2048" 115256 144500 182987 184373 205374 186811 176171 138013 122092 158562
"4096" 110244 130671 147163 165267 171374 168865 150516 127664 112130 104482 143891
"8192" 106454 126110 144240 157632 164260 162323 150201 129724 111518 103452 102031 139726
"16384" 105330 125518 144111 157397 161881 161278 147959 129013 110130 103192 101404 101440 137670
"32768" 0 0 0 0 161534 160154 148485 128800 110994 102274 100757 100325 99373
"65536" 0 0 0 0 159839 159476 148300 130085 110836 101668 99703 100152 99683
"131072" 0 0 0 0 159492 158811 149204 130765 111203 101366 99553 99576 99691
"262144" 0 0 0 0 158988 158328 149257 131044 110729 101779 99474 99301 99000
"524288" 0 0 0 0 157407 155071 147016 130355 110483 101617 99468 99360 98517
"Fread report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 286849 467002 503814 359444 477808
"128" 499970 408949 509943 606767 492178 430942
"256" 466275 585845 585845 474937 802014 663292 716876
"512" 355319 438011 755144 748563 435700 851903 584539 537838
"1024" 557729 580181 703769 749583 722230 630518 585799 354815 274372
"2048" 329421 376259 442442 396602 436484 382151 380594 277248 230343 196566
"4096" 287843 326664 338067 318956 330561 310516 277278 260807 209105 183070 172987
"8192" 280607 313196 319861 323115 319251 308757 280433 243165 204121 176134 170414 166399
"16384" 278957 308525 320895 322360 314654 308800 287292 248796 199120 175926 168331 168344 162533
"32768" 0 0 0 0 318898 309672 289408 251369 205200 175730 167505 166179 166405
"65536" 0 0 0 0 319251 312052 293892 217541 209171 174694 164013 165121 164091
"131072" 0 0 0 0 325895 318138 298919 260470 212527 176033 164871 164213 164304
"262144" 0 0 0 0 326698 318906 299027 262557 211268 175330 164752 163170 163817
"524288" 0 0 0 0 325485 319095 299433 259933 212147 176806 164713 163519 163326
"Re-Fread report"
"4" "8" "16" "32" "64" "128" "256" "512" "1024" "2048" "4096" "8192" "16384"
"64" 378715 503814 659861 385237 587635
"128" 547377 387686 537512 677178 517812 621518
"256" 519266 618584 510866 576411 792543 716876 856386
"512" 392678 466255 798675 784094 606667 855978 695472 467575
"1024" 374687 591201 768219 804330 793189 708646 679067 420506 273864
"2048" 352627 403533 480399 404731 476297 396437 400952 284644 233417 192898
"4096" 282248 326738 341020 325340 332416 317958 293915 261893 210126 181473 172688
"8192" 281455 313079 322836 323553 314342 308248 286644 252691 203129 179028 168824 166068
"16384" 276503 310062 319214 317809 315860 310074 281893 253007 203740 176835 169053 166060 160600
"32768" 0 0 0 0 321566 313030 294488 257644 213604 177497 165933 164616 164719
"65536" 0 0 0 0 325261 319301 300441 261817 212611 175282 164483 164877 164078
"131072" 0 0 0 0 326394 319006 299437 259510 213064 176177 164751 163900 164366
"262144" 0 0 0 0 326258 319312 299670 262988 207711 176267 164337 163176 163616
"524288" 0 0 0 0 325701 319083 299173 260064 212352 176594 164703 163467 163262
real 14m34.837s
user 0m47.578s
sys 13m17.443sIOzone writer report plotted with LibreOffice Calc.
IOzone reader report plotted with LibreOffice Calc.
High Performance Conjugate Gradient Benchmark (HPCG)
HPCG is another benchmark for ranking HPC systems. As per the HPCG page it’s …designed to exercise computational and data access patterns that more closely match a different and broad set of important applications, and to give incentive to computer system designers to invest in capabilities that will have impact on the collective performance of these applications. In other words, it’s designed to give a more rounded assessment of the capabilites of a system as opposed to HPL. HPCG may provide a more rounded assessment of a system and how it will perform with real world applications.
Like HPL, I built HPCG using the standard Ubuntu supplied compilers, OpenMPI and other libraries. So this is not really considered to be an optimized run.
The result from the HPCG run follows:
Final Summary=
Final Summary::HPCG result is VALID with a GFLOP/s rating of=0.167441
Final Summary::HPCG 2.4 rating for historical reasons is=0.168344
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeDotProduct used=Performance results a
re most likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeSPMV used=Performance results are mos
t likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeMG used=Performance results are most
likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeWAXPBY used=Performance results are m
ost likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Results are valid but execution time (sec) is=761.216
Final Summary::Official results execution time (sec) must be at least=1800ubuntu@unmatched:~/hpcg/bin$ more HPCG-Benchmark_3.1_2021-07-08_19-18-43.txt
HPCG-Benchmark
version=3.1
Release date=March 28, 2019
Machine Summary=
Machine Summary::Distributed Processes=4
Machine Summary::Threads per processes=1
Global Problem Dimensions=
Global Problem Dimensions::Global nx=240
Global Problem Dimensions::Global ny=240
Global Problem Dimensions::Global nz=120
Processor Dimensions=
Processor Dimensions::npx=2
Processor Dimensions::npy=2
Processor Dimensions::npz=1
Local Domain Dimensions=
Local Domain Dimensions::nx=120
Local Domain Dimensions::ny=120
Local Domain Dimensions::Lower ipz=0
Local Domain Dimensions::Upper ipz=0
Local Domain Dimensions::nz=120
########## Problem Summary ##########=
Setup Information=
Setup Information::Setup Time=41.0377
Linear System Information=
Linear System Information::Number of Equations=6912000
Linear System Information::Number of Nonzero Terms=184557592
Multigrid Information=
Multigrid Information::Number of coarse grid levels=3
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids=
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Equations=864000
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Nonzero Terms=22813192
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Presmoother Steps=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Postsmoother Steps=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=2
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Equations=108000
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Nonzero Terms=2788192
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Presmoother Steps=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Postsmoother Steps=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=3
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Equations=13500
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Nonzero Terms=332992
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Presmoother Steps=1
Multigrid Information::Coarse Grids::Number of Postsmoother Steps=1
########## Memory Use Summary ##########=
Memory Use Information=
Memory Use Information::Total memory used for data (Gbytes)=4.94251
Memory Use Information::Memory used for OptimizeProblem data (Gbytes)=0
Memory Use Information::Bytes per equation (Total memory / Number of Equations)=
715.063
Memory Use Information::Memory used for linear system and CG (Gbytes)=4.3495
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids=
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=1
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Memory used=0.519816
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=2
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Memory used=0.0650476
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Grid Level=3
Memory Use Information::Coarse Grids::Memory used=0.00814937
########## V&V Testing Summary ##########=
Spectral Convergence Tests=
Spectral Convergence Tests::Result=PASSED
Spectral Convergence Tests::Unpreconditioned=
Spectral Convergence Tests::Unpreconditioned::Maximum iteration count=11
Spectral Convergence Tests::Unpreconditioned::Expected iteration count=12
Spectral Convergence Tests::Preconditioned=
Spectral Convergence Tests::Preconditioned::Maximum iteration count=2
Spectral Convergence Tests::Preconditioned::Expected iteration count=2
Departure from Symmetry |x'Ay-y'Ax|/(2*||x||*||A||*||y||)/epsilon=
Departure from Symmetry |x'Ay-y'Ax|/(2*||x||*||A||*||y||)/epsilon::Result=PASSED
Departure from Symmetry |x'Ay-y'Ax|/(2*||x||*||A||*||y||)/epsilon::Departure for
SpMV=2.57379e-08
Departure from Symmetry |x'Ay-y'Ax|/(2*||x||*||A||*||y||)/epsilon::Departure for
MG=1.89158e-08
########## Iterations Summary ##########=
Iteration Count Information=
Iteration Count Information::Result=PASSED
Iteration Count Information::Reference CG iterations per set=50
Iteration Count Information::Optimized CG iterations per set=50
Iteration Count Information::Total number of reference iterations=50
Iteration Count Information::Total number of optimized iterations=50
########## Reproducibility Summary ##########=
Reproducibility Information=
Reproducibility Information::Result=PASSED
Reproducibility Information::Scaled residual mean=0.000139647
Reproducibility Information::Scaled residual variance=0
########## Performance Summary (times in sec) ##########=
Benchmark Time Summary=
Benchmark Time Summary::Optimization phase=1e-06
Benchmark Time Summary::DDOT=20.1473
Benchmark Time Summary::WAXPBY=14.5966
Benchmark Time Summary::SpMV=103.923
Benchmark Time Summary::MG=622.465
Benchmark Time Summary::Total=761.216
Floating Point Operations Summary=
Floating Point Operations Summary::Raw DDOT=2.08742e+09
Floating Point Operations Summary::Raw WAXPBY=2.08742e+09
Floating Point Operations Summary::Raw SpMV=1.88249e+10
Floating Point Operations Summary::Raw MG=1.05146e+11
Floating Point Operations Summary::Total=1.28146e+11
Floating Point Operations Summary::Total with convergence overhead=1.28146e+11
GB/s Summary=
GB/s Summary::Raw Read B/W=1.03717
GB/s Summary::Raw Write B/W=0.23969
GB/s Summary::Raw Total B/W=1.27686
GB/s Summary::Total with convergence and optimization phase overhead=1.27001
GFLOP/s Summary=
GFLOP/s Summary::Raw DDOT=0.103608
GFLOP/s Summary::Raw WAXPBY=0.143007
GFLOP/s Summary::Raw SpMV=0.181142
GFLOP/s Summary::Raw MG=0.168919
GFLOP/s Summary::Raw Total=0.168344
GFLOP/s Summary::Total with convergence overhead=0.168344
GFLOP/s Summary::Total with convergence and optimization phase overhead=0.167441
User Optimization Overheads=
User Optimization Overheads::Optimization phase time (sec)=1e-06
User Optimization Overheads::Optimization phase time vs reference SpMV+MG time=6
.85121e-08
DDOT Timing Variations=
DDOT Timing Variations::Min DDOT MPI_Allreduce time=6.31348
DDOT Timing Variations::Max DDOT MPI_Allreduce time=10.9565
DDOT Timing Variations::Avg DDOT MPI_Allreduce time=8.88789
Final Summary=
Final Summary::HPCG result is VALID with a GFLOP/s rating of=0.167441
Final Summary::HPCG 2.4 rating for historical reasons is=0.168344
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeDotProduct used=Performance results a
re most likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeSPMV used=Performance results are mos
t likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeMG used=Performance results are most
likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Reference version of ComputeWAXPBY used=Performance results are m
ost likely suboptimal
Final Summary::Results are valid but execution time (sec) is=761.216
Final Summary::Official results execution time (sec) must be at least=1800syslog-ng
And for something different to close out. Peter Czanik of One Identity ran through some benchmarks of syslog-ng on Unmatched. Peter noted that the Unmatched is between the Raspberry Pi 3 and the SolidRun macchitoBIN. The boards were tested using a simple script generating various synthetic loads for stress testing of syslog-ng. The Raspberry Pi 3 was only faster when there was a low number of concurrent connections using a complex configuration. For all other tests of syslog-ng, the Unmatched board was faster. For higher loads, performance of the Unmatched board was close to the macchiatoBIN, which is a quad-core Cortex A-72 based board. For the sake of comparison, the same syslog-ng benchmarks ran more than 15x faster on an entry level AMD Ryzen desktop CPU.
syslog-ng benchmark results.
For more details, feel free to reach out to Peter on Twitter.
Thanks to @gabor_samu I had some remote access to a @SiFive Unmatched #RiscV board. Of course I tested it with syslog-ng. It's performance seems to be better than @Raspberry_Pi 3 but slightly slower than a @solid_run MacchiatoBIN.https://t.co/ObM9LTgtq1
— Peter Czanik (@PCzanik) June 10, 2021
That concludes this post. What struck me was how easily I could compile things such as HPL, HPCG on the system. Certainly, there are no record breaking results to report here, but that was anticipated. Personally, I’m really keen to see how RISCV develops over time. Indeed, it’s certainly something which is being eyed for HPC. Take for example the European Processor Initiative (EPI) where the (vector) accelerator will rely upon RISCV. So I’d wager that the future is bright for RISCV in HPC - and as the saying goes, variety is the spice of life.